Performance comparison GRASS vs. ArcGIS: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
mNo edit summary |
m (remove under construction notice) |
||
| (5 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
[[Category:ArcGIS]] | [[Category:ArcGIS]] | ||
== Longest flow path == | |||
''The r.accumulate module implements a fast longest flow path algorithm for hydrologic modeling.'' ([https://twitter.com/HuidaeCho/status/1279868419119210497 Quote: Twitter], [https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsoft.2020.104774 Test: Paper]) | |||
== Vector buffer (special case) == | == Vector buffer (special case) == | ||
| Line 6: | Line 9: | ||
:'''Input data:''' Vector layer 'StatPolygon' from [http://www.arcdata.cz/produkty-a-sluzby/geograficka-data/arccr-500/ ArcCR500] dataset | :'''Input data:''' Vector layer 'StatPolygon' from [http://www.arcdata.cz/produkty-a-sluzby/geograficka-data/arccr-500/ ArcCR500] dataset | ||
:'''Comparison:''' Windows Server Enterprise {{bullet}} Intel Xeon CPU E5520 2.27GHz 2.26GHz (2 processors) {{bullet}} 8GB {{bullet}} 64bit OS | :'''Comparison:''' Windows Server Enterprise {{bullet}} Intel Xeon CPU E5520 2.27GHz 2.26GHz (2 processors) {{bullet}} 8GB {{bullet}} 64bit OS | ||
::*GRASS 7: <code>v.buffer input=StatPolygon output=Stat_5000 distance=-5000</code> → '''12sec''' | ::*'''GRASS 7:''' <code>v.buffer input=StatPolygon output=Stat_5000 distance=-5000</code> → '''12sec''' | ||
::*ArcGIS 10.2: <code>Buffer StatPolygon Stat_5000 "-5000 Meters" FULL ROUND NONE</code> → '''6min 50sec''' | ::*'''ArcGIS 10.2.0:''' <code>Buffer StatPolygon Stat_5000 "-5000 Meters" FULL ROUND NONE</code> → '''6min 50sec''' | ||
{{fig|buffer-negative-distance|Vector buffer with negative distance (GRASS)|size=640}} | {{fig|buffer-negative-distance|Vector buffer with negative distance (GRASS)|size=640}} | ||
{{fig|arcgis-buffer-negative-distance|Vector buffer with negative distance (ArcGIS)|size=640}} | {{fig|arcgis-buffer-negative-distance|Vector buffer with negative distance (ArcGIS)|size=640}} | ||
== Clipping Contest Benchmark == | |||
ContourClipTest with ArcGIS, QGIS, GlobalMapper, Manifold, JGRASS ... (tests done in 2011): | |||
https://courses.neteler.org/arcgis-vs-qgis-etc-clipping-contest-rematch-revisited/ | |||
== See also == | |||
* [[GRASS GIS Performance]] | |||
Latest revision as of 03:12, 3 February 2025
Longest flow path
The r.accumulate module implements a fast longest flow path algorithm for hydrologic modeling. (Quote: Twitter, Test: Paper)
Vector buffer (special case)
- Task: Create buffer around vector polygon with negative distance
- Input data: Vector layer 'StatPolygon' from ArcCR500 dataset
- Comparison: Windows Server Enterprise • Intel Xeon CPU E5520 2.27GHz 2.26GHz (2 processors) • 8GB • 64bit OS
- GRASS 7:
v.buffer input=StatPolygon output=Stat_5000 distance=-5000→ 12sec - ArcGIS 10.2.0:
Buffer StatPolygon Stat_5000 "-5000 Meters" FULL ROUND NONE→ 6min 50sec
- GRASS 7:
Clipping Contest Benchmark
ContourClipTest with ArcGIS, QGIS, GlobalMapper, Manifold, JGRASS ... (tests done in 2011):
https://courses.neteler.org/arcgis-vs-qgis-etc-clipping-contest-rematch-revisited/